Indiana Man's Elaborate Frame Job Using Social Media to Send Innocent Man to Jail For Murder Revealed

Police say that Nigel "Nati Bang" Thomas launched an elaborate scheme to cover his tracks and frame someone else for the crime

By
Thomas
Nigel "Nati Bang" Thomas, 34 Jefferson County Prosecutor

A man who was framed for murder through social media has been set free, and Indiana police say they now have the real murderer in custody.

On April 14, police were called to check on Wilma Robertson in Hanover, Indiana. Inside, police found the 35-year-old woman stabbed to death.

Police say Robertson's killer was Nigel "Nati Bang" Thomas and that Thomas launched an elaborate scheme to cover his tracks and frame someone else for the crime.

Police allege that the 34-year-old Thomas sought to frame Shawn Bailey for the murder by creating numerous social media accounts under Bailey's name. Then, after the killing, Thomas sent out messages to relatives of Robertson pretending to be Bailey and admitting to the murder.

The ruse briefly worked, as police initially arrested Bailey, 33, of Louisville, Kentucky, on April 15. Police dismissed the charges on April 25 based on accumulating evidence, including a DNA analysis that ruled Bailey out as a suspect.

"The criminal justice system is ultimately a search for the truth. Multiple agencies across three states worked tirelessly in their pursuit of all investigative leads to uncover the crimes of Nigel Thomas and clear Shawn Bailey", said Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter.

Tags
Indiana, Murder, Stabbing, Social Media

© 2026 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Tepe

Chilling Twist in Ohio Dentist and Wife's Murder As New Detail From Inside Home Surfaces

jeri

Terrified Indiana Kids' Desperate 911 Calls During Mom's Horrific Murder Revealed: 'My Dad Is Shooting My Mom'

Nanon Williams

Death Row Inmate Says Michelle Reiner Emailed Him Just Hours Before being Murdered In Own Home

Tepe

Family of Murdered Ohio Dentist and Wife Downplays New Evidence As Mystery Surrounding Killings Deepens