North Carolina Man Obsessed With Ex After Breakup Strangled Single Mom of 4 With Power Cord: Prosecutors

Trenton David Mills Frye, 31, faces a first-degree murder charge in the October 2022 death of his ex-girlfriend

By
WSET
Trenton David Mills Frye, 31, is on trial for murder. WSET

A North Carolina man became so obsessed with a woman following a breakup that he tracked her down and strangled her, prosecutors said during opening arguments of a murder trial.

Trenton David Mills Frye, 31, faces a first-degree murder charge in the October 2022 death of his ex-girlfriend, Katlyn Lyon Montgomery, newsadvance.com reported.

Prosecutors alleged that after Montgomery dumped Frye, he became angry and obsessed with the single mother of four who managed a steak and sushi restaurant. Frye, prosecutors said, was behind on child support payments to another woman and eventually found Montgomery despite the fact that she moved after the breakup, newsadvanced.com reported.

After Montgomery was strangled with what police believe was a power cord, they questioned Frye, who said he was in Virginia at the time of the killing and did not know where Montgomery lived. However, according to an arrest affidavit, Frye's cell phone pinged a tower on the day of Montgomery's death about a mile from her apartment.

The documents also state the couple had broken up about a week before her death and that the night before she died, on October 6, 2022, the two were involved in an argument via text messages.

Joseph Sanzone, Frye's attorney, told jurors that his client is innocent.

"Did something happen to Katlyn? Absolutely," Sanzone said, according to newsadvance.com. "There's no evidence thatshows Trenton was ever in the apartment."

Tags
North Carolina, Murder

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Berman

Woman Accused of Stabbing Husband Wrote Ominous Clue on Her Calendar For Day He Died, Prosecutors Say

Tyler James Robinson

Tyler Robinson's Texts Talking About Shooting Just Minutes After Allegedly Killing Charlie Kirk Revealed: "You See The News?"

Nick Reiner

Rob Reiner's Son Kept Out of Court As Charges Related to Parent's Murder Loom

Rob Reiner

Rob Reiner Loudly Argued With Son At Conan's Christmas Party Hours Before Murder: Report