Woman Who Stole Human Toes Hoping to Sell Them On the Black Market Will Spend No Time in Jail

The toes had been thrown up by dogs, who had consumed them after their owner passed away

By
Joanna Kathlyn Kinman
Joanna Kathlyn Kinman, 48, retrieved human toes vomited up by dogs, hoping to sell them on the black market. 7NEWS Australia / YouTube

An Australian woman who stole human toes from an animal shelter's trash with plans to sell them online has avoided jail time.

Joanna Kathlyn Kinman, 48, worked at an animal shelter where, in February 2024, two surrendered dogs vomited up human toes they had consumed after their owner died of natural causes, as reported by the Sydney Morning Herald.

The remains were discarded, but Kinman reportedly retrieved the toes, preserved them in formaldehyde and researched selling them online, believing they could fetch AU$400, or about $254. Police discovered them at her home after receiving a tip.

Kinman, an active member of the online group Bone Buddies Australia, where human and animal remains were discussed and traded, pleaded guilty to offensive conduct involving human remains.

Prosecutors detailed her collection of macabre items, including an alligator claw, a guinea pig trotter and her children's baby teeth. The court found her behavior disturbing but ruled that it did not warrant jail time.

On Monday, Kinman was sentenced to an 18-month community corrections order with 150 hours of community service. She also lost her job and faced significant online backlash.

The 48-year-old's defense lawyer emphasized her remorse and argued that her actions were impulsive rather than malicious.

Tags
Jail, Australia

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Tyler James Robinson

Former US Attorney Shuts Down Possible 'Insanity' Defense For Accused Kirk Assassin

horror home

'Pure Evil' Pennsylvania Horror House Where Cops Found 3 Dead Babies Revealed

storage

Milwaukee Residents Shocked After Cops Free 6 Children From Storage Unit in Middle of Night: 'Don't Even Know How to Respond'

Nichole

Texas Mom Who Confessed to Slitting 5-Year-Old's Throat Dodges Prison Time