Longest-Serving Female Inmate, Betty Smithey, Now Free After 49 Years in Prison

By

On Tuesday, Betty Smithey walked out of the Arizona State Prison Complex in Perryville, a free woman after serving 49-years in prison for a murder in 1963.

Smithey, now 69, was charged and convicted of the murder of 15-month-old, Sandy Gerberick, whom she was baby-sitting. Smithey was 20 at the time. The murder came to be called as The New Year's Day Murder. She has also been accused of kidnapping Mitchel Johnson in 1959.

Smithey was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. According to the Law, anyone who receives a term of life in prison before 1973 is labeled considered an "old-code lifer," according to the Iquisitor, this means that only the State governor could grant clemency. After she repeatedly appealed to then Arizona-governors Fyfe Symington and later Janet Napolitano, both of who denied her clemency.

Finally in June, the current state governor Jan Brewer, the current governor, accepted her plea and lowered her sentence to a 48 year prison term. She was granted parole by the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency on Monday in a 4-1 vote. And Tuesday was allowed to set foot outside the confinement of barbed wires and metal bars.

Andy Silverman, Attorney of Smithey told Yahoo News, "She's absolutely not a threat to society. She's almost 70 years old now...She's done a lot of reflection. Forty-nine years in prison, you think a lot about what you've been through."

Smithey, who has suffered from a number of serious health problems while in prison, including breast cancer, will be living with her niece in Mesa, Arizona.

"It's wonderful driving down the road and not seeing any barbed wire...I'm lucky," she said according to Yahoo News.

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More News
High School Lacrosse Team Facing Kidnapping Charges as Staged Abduction

High School Lacrosse Team Faces Kidnapping Charges as Staged Abduction Went 'Way Beyond Hazing'

7-Year-Old Stole Mom’s Car to Drive Little Sister to McDonald’s

7-Year-Old Stole Mom's Car to Drive Little Sister to McDonald's. Mom Says He Wants 'Be a Truck Driver Someday'

Drug Dealing Uber_04302025_1

Uber Driver Wearing 'Retired Drug Dealer' Shirt Arrested for Drug Trafficking: Police

New Jersey Off Duty_04292025_1

Off-Duty Female Officer Broke Into New Jersey Home and Assaulted 2 Victims Before Resisting Arrest: Police