New York Double Homicide Suspect Is All Smiles as He's Arrested in Florida McDonald's Parking Lot

McDonald's tipster cashes in $10,000

By
Florida police arrested New York double homicide suspect Scott Mitchell
Florida police arrested New York double homicide suspect Scott Mitchell in a Daytona Beach McDonald's parking lot after a statewide manhunt. Volusia Sheriff's Office

A fugitive wanted for a double homicide in New York was captured at a Florida McDonald's parking lot and grinned as officers took him into custody.

Since February 3, authorities have been on the hunt for Scott Mitchell, 50, who is accused of murdering two people in Binghamton, New York.

"Double murder suspect Scott Mitchell is in custody in Daytona Beach. The person who called in the tip just earned $10,000," police announced on Facebook Wednesday.

Mitchell's capture cracked people up online, with many mocking his smug demeanor.

"Glad to see him smiling... so glad he's in custody!!" one Facebook user wrote.

"The McDonald's employees are stepping their game up... they can't get our orders correct to save their lives, but they are 2-0 on murderers!" another said.

"Love the look on the cop's face, cat got the cream for sure, well done," another commented.

While authorities have not disclosed further details on Mitchell's arrest, officials had previously warned the public not to approach him as he was considered armed and dangerous.

"Scott Mitchell, if you see this, you need to come back to New York. You need to pay for what you've done to my brother and his friend. You need to give our family some closure because we don't sleep at night knowing you're out there," Lisa Callahan, the sister of victim Marshall VanOven, previously told local news.

Tags
Florida, Murder, McDonalds, New York

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More News
House Door

Texas Teens Playing 'Ding Dong Ditch' Flee For Their Lives After Homeowner Opens Fire At Their Car

Tina Peters

Trump Demands Release of 'Innocent Patriot' Tina Peters Jailed by 'Crooked Colorado Politicians'

Alabama AG Accuses TikTok of Fueling Teen Mental Health Decline

TikTok Hit With Minnesota Lawsuit Claiming It Fuels Teen Mental Health Crisis

Convicted killer Lori Daybell

'Doomsday Mom' Lori Daybell Explained: The Chilling Murder Trial, Explosive Verdict, and Netflix Doc