Trump's NY Hush Money Case Takes Chaotic Turn as Defense Witness Rebuke by Judge

By

Trump Trial Enters a Challenging Stage

The drama escalated to new heights on Monday in the ongoing trial of former President Trump. At the core of the courtroom spectacle, a judge took the extraordinary step of admonishing a defense witness for what he deemed improper behavior. The tense exchange unfolded as the prosecution rested its case, sharply focusing on the defense's actions.

The incident involved Robert Costello, a former legal advisor to Michael Cohen, Trump's former fixer who has been a central figure due to his hush money payment, which is at the heart of the case. Prosecutors have anchored their case on Cohen's testimony, outlining a narrative of a pressure campaign to prevent him from flipping as federal investigators zeroed in back in 2018.

Judge's Stern Message

The trial's atmosphere took on charged energy as Costello took the stand. The witness' audible remarks and noticeable reactions to objections did not sit well with Judge Juan Merchan. The situation escalated quickly, resulting in Judge Merchan instructing the press to leave the courtroom first during the trial.

The judge's reprimand was clear. Judge Merchan laid out his expectations for courtroom behavior, directly addressing Costello and emphasizing the proceedings' seriousness. Despite the heightened moment, the specifics of the discussion once the press was removed remain unclear. After being allowed to re-enter, journalists were not provided with an explanation for the unusual interruption.

Trump Outcry Unfolds

Adding to the chaos, Trump reacted, characterizing the judge's actions as unprecedented and conflicted. As reporters and the press absorbed what had occurred, Trump's criticism was pointed, suggesting judicial impropriety. Throughout the trial, high-stakes moments have brought sharp reactions, but the exit from the courtroom marked a particularly striking chapter.

Defense Strategies Take Center Stage

Notwithstanding the courtroom drama, Trump's defense team pressed on with their arguments. As they pushed back against the charges, raising questions about the legitimacy of the records, the defense set their sights on Cohen himself. They attempted to pick apart his credibility, suggesting he was lying. Trump's lawyers even asked the judge to deem Cohen untrustworthy as a matter of law, which would strip the jury of evaluating his reliability- a bold legal strategy indeed.

The challenge for Trump's attorneys remains to dismantle the state's case against their client, steadily reinforcing their notion that keeping negative stories hidden is not inherently criminal.

Closing Phases Imminent

With the prosecution having rested after approximately four weeks and 20 witnesses, the spotlight remains firmly planted on the defense as they aim to unravel the state's allegations. They motioned to dismiss Trump's 34 charges for falsifying business records, arguing that proof falls short.

As the defense nears the end of their witness lineup, with Costello expected to wrap his testimony, the trial is moving toward its decisive conclusion. The stitches of legal discourse woven throughout the courtroom suggest that the coming days will be enveloped by critical closing statements following the Memorial Day holiday as the world watches the crux of American justice unfold.

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More Hot Issues
Florida Officials Threaten Protesters With Death Ahead of ‘No Kings’

Florida Officials Threaten Protesters With Death Ahead of 'No Kings' Protest: 'We Will Kill You Graveyard Dead'

Golden Slams Padilla_06132025_1

Democrat Rips Into Fellow Party Member After He Was Detained During Kristi Noem Press Conference: 'Theater'

Philadelphia Police Caught on Camera Kneeling on ICE Protester's Neck

Philadelphia Police Caught on Camera Kneeling on ICE Protester's Neck as Crowd Screams, Sparking Outrage Online

Teacher Gets License Revoked After Explicit OnlyFans Photos of ‘Good

Teacher's License Revoked After Explicit OnlyFans Photos of 'Good Teacher Gone Bad' Leaked to Students