Angry Customers Overcharged To About $14M Over 3 Years, Dunkin Donuts Lawsuit Claims

By

A new Dunkin Donuts lawsuit filed by angry customers from New Jersey and New York says that the donut company overcharged them to almost $14 million over the course of three years. The lawsuit alleges that the company ripped off the customers by taxing non-taxable food items.

Customers of the said branches said that the company doesn't know how sales tax works. As per Dunkin Donuts' lawsuit, a store operating in Ft. Lee, New Jersey claimed that they charged the state 7% sales tax on unsweetened bottled water and bags of ground coffee which is a violation of the law, New York Post reveals. A second lawsuit says that a branch close to Manhattan's Penn Station charged customers on sales tax for pre-packaged coffee beans.

"Dunkin' should stop dunking their customers and provide customers with refunds or discounts so they are made whole," Carl Mayer, a lawyer who filed the lawsuits told The New York Post. The attorney also cited that a dozen different Dunkin' Donuts locations overcharged customers about 70% of the time.

Mayer also stressed that the company reaped Dunkin Donuts customers $10 million for overcharges and $4 million for overcharging on sales tax in New Jersey for three years, Consumerist reports. In an effort to respond to Dunkin Donuts' lawsuit, the company said in an email that the over 1,000 stores in New York and New Jersey are franchisees and they should comply with the federal law when it comes to tax implementations.

"We are in the process of reaching out to the franchisees identified in the complaint in order to determine whether these taxes were charged to customers," the company said, according to App.com.

Dunkin Donuts' lawsuit also claims that the company continues to overcharge customers through sales tax despite the mounting customer complaints and media publicity. In their latest statement, they said that they are now working to resolve the issues.

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More Law & Society
Miguel Mike Mirabal Discusses the Role of Integrity and Equity

Miguel Mike Mirabal Discusses the Role of Integrity and Equity in Global Legal Practice

Jan 6 DOJ Appointment_07022025_1

Trump Picks Pardoned Capitol Rioter Who Encouraged Violence Against Police to Serve as DOJ Adviser

Trump Revives Idea of Deporting Criminals ‘Born in Our Country’:

Trump Revives Idea of Deporting US Citizen Criminals 'We Ought to Get Them the Hell Out of Here'

Tennessee Man Used Drone to Deliver Marijuana to Inmate in

Michigan Bank Robber Coaxed Out of Standoff With Soda Dangling From Drone Before Police Shot Him