'Making A Murderer' Subject Steven Avery Files New Appeal, Says Members of the Jury Were Bullied

By

Making A Murderer’s main subject, Steven Avery, has filed a new appeal requesting the judge to dismiss his murder conviction of killing Teresa Halbach. Avery filed the court documents on Jan. 7th and were processed by the Wisconsin court system four days later.

Avery claims that a juror bullied the rest of the panel into declaring him guilty of Teresa Halbach’s murder, Entertainment Weekly reports. The court documents identified the juror as “C.W”, the person who allegedly made “repeated” comments that Avery was “F—ing guilty”.

“If you can’t handle it why don’t you tell them and just leave,” reads another alleged statement from CW.

It was Avery who represented himself on Jan. 7th. At that time, he argued that the juror “had [notions of] preconceived guilt,” which “deprived Avery of an impartial jury trial”.

According to the publication, it’s likely that Avery is referring to Carl Wardman as the “bully” among the jurors. Wardman volunteered with the Manitowoc County Sheriff’s Dept. while the case against Avery was still ongoing.

In a report from TMZ, Avery also claimed that the police search that might have produce incriminating evidence (blood and key found on Halbach’s car) was illegal. He asserts that the officials exceeded the limits of the search warrant.

The lead prosecutor on the case, Ken Kratz, released a statement following Avery’s appeal.

"I'm disappointed that Mr. Avery's appellate lawyers are allowing him to continue to file pleadings with the court on his own - that's what lawys are hired to do. And this appears to be an example of Mr. Avery doing exactly what he wants to and when he wants to do it,” he said in a report from CNN.

Avery is currently waiting for the Wisconsin Court of Appeals to rule on his favor to declare a mistrial.

Tags
Netflix

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More Law & Society
GOP Senator Blames US Citizens Mistakenly Detained by ICE Instead

GOP Senator to US Citizens: 'Don't Hang Around Illegals' If You Don't Want to Be Detained

‘Don’t You Dare Ever Say That Again’: Kristi Noem ‘Threatens’

'Don't You Dare Ever Say That Again': Kristi Noem 'Threatens' Reporter Over Question of ICE Racial Profiling

No Amnesty_07182025_1

GOP Lawmakers Ridicule Republican Colleague's Bill to Allow Some Migrants to Obtain Citizenship: 'No Amnesty'

Vance Defends Trump WSJ_07182025_1

Vance Bashes Journalists for 'Not Asking Questions' About Epstein Case in Resurfaced Clip After Blasting WSJ Report