Florida Jewelry Thief Finally 'Passes' $770K Earrings He Swallowed Month After Stealing Them: 'Quickly Turned to A Marathon, Not a Sprint'

Recovery of the stolen jewelry was described as "laborious"

By
Swallowed earrings
Body scan of Jaythan Gilder, 32, with diamonds in his stomach. Orlando Police Department

Florida police have finally recovered, and cleaned, $769,000 worth of stolen jewelry that was swallowed by a suspect several weeks ago.

Describing the effort to recover the diamond earrings as "laborious," the Orlando Police Department announced on Facebook that the jewelry taken in a February 26 botched heist had been recovered after about 12 days.

"This case quickly turned into a marathon, not a sprint," Detective Aaron Goss said.

According to police, on February 26, Jaythan Gilder, 32, entered a Tiffany & Co. store and pretended to be an assistant to an Orlando Magic basketball player. Gilder convinced staff to show him "very high-end" pieces of jewelry. The staff took Gilder to it's private VIP room to show him the jewelry.

Police said that Gilder then took a ring valued at $575,000 and earrings valued at $780,000 and escaped the store. Eventually, police were able to track down his vehicle, but as the Florida Highway Patrol arrested him they noticed "items in his mouth that he was attempting to swallow," Goss said.

After a body scan confirmed the stolen earrings were inside Gilder, the wait began.

"Later, after the items were expelled from his system, we were able to take the diamonds to Tiffany's, where they were cleaned," Goss said. He added that the master jeweler examined the items and was able to identify the serial numbers on the items, confirming that they were the items taken on February 26.

Gilder faces charges of grand theft and robbery with a mask.

Tags
Florida, Police, Theft

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Glenn McIntosh

Ohio Mom's Haunting Texts to Boyfriend After He Allegedly Bashed Her Daughter's Skull: 'You Killed My Baby Girl'

Allison Hatton

Florida Man Went on Stabbing Spree Inside Home to Get Family 'Up to Heaven', Cops Say

Ellen Greenberg

Pennsylvania Family Rips New Report Claiming Woman With Over 20 Stab Wounds Killed Herself

Antonio Charmon Pearce

Georgia Dad's 'Questionable' Tale About Young Son's Gunpoint Kidnapping Quickly Fell Apart, Cops Say