Accused Serial Killer Rex Heuermann Moves to Have Key DNA Evidence Tossed Out Of Court

Defense attorneys for accused Long Island serial killer Rex Heuermann want to block key DNA evidence

By
Rex Heuermann
Rex Heuermann Suffolk County Sheriff's Office

Defense attorneys for accused Long Island serial killer Rex Heuermann want to block key DNA evidence from being considered in the case that stretches back decades.

The move prompted a delay in Heuermann's scheduled court proceedings. A Tuesday court date for Heuermann has now been pushed back to January 29 to give prosecutors an opportunity to file their response before a hearing is scheduled on the matter, Newsday reported.

Prosecutors allege that Heuermann is the "Gilgo Beach" serial killer, who murdered seven woman dating back to the 1990s, NBC 4 reported. Police discovered the bodies of four of the women in burlap sacks along Gilgo Beach's Ocean Parkway on Long Island in 2010, and Heuermann has been charged in three of those cases. Heuermann has pleaded not guilty to all charges.

After the four bodies were discovered, police began finding other remains along the stretch of road, including Valerie Mack who disappeared in 2000. Heuermann was charged in Mack's death in December of 2024, Patch.com reported.

Heuermann also is charged in the murder of Sandra Costilla, which dates back to 1993, NBC 4 reported. Costilla's body was found by some hunters in a wooded area of Southampton.

Initially, the New York architect was charged with three murders when he was first arrested in July 2023; that number has risen to seven. DNA is a key aspect of the evidence against Heuermann.

The case will involve a new type of DNA testing, not previously used in New York, Patch reported. The yet-to-be-scheduled hearing will determine the admissibility of the evidence that has been gathered based on that testing.

Tags
Serial Killer, New York, Murder, Murder investigation

© 2025 Lawyer Herald All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Discussion
More True Crime
Former MLB Pitcher Guilty of Father-in-Law’s ‘Execution-Style’ Murder

Former MLB Pitcher Guilty of Father-in-Law's 'Execution-Style' Murder

Hershall Creachbaum

'Kidnapped' Ohio Boy With Autism Found Dead Hours Later Was Likely Dead For Weeks, Authorities Say, As Mom Faces Charges

Son of Hollywood Exec Who Dismembered His Wife And Her

Son of Hollywood Exec Who Dismembered His Wife And Her Parents Commits 'One Last Cruel Act' Behind Bars

Elizabeth Drake mugshot

Wisconsin Woman Ignored Bedridden Mom's Cries For Help For Months While Running True Crime Facebook Blog